So this is crazy. Apparently this is getting a reboot already, instead of a sequel.
More details here:
“The Lords of the Fallen is the spiritual successor fans of the original title have always wanted,” said Virtosu. “The game is significantly larger, with a vast, interconnected dual world split between the realms of the living and dead, that players can explore alone or with friends. It’s darker and more challenging, with faster soulslike combat, stronger thematic, richer narrative, deeper RPG systems, and more immersive storytelling.”
Gameplay trailer coming later this year.
So the first game was Lords of the Fallen, and this is “The Lords of the Fallen”.