My thoughts so far:
Maybe midway or so through Chapter 2? Don’t know. RDR was a favorite, though I had issues with the non-random repeating stranger encounters, and hated the Mexico segment. But I was not really feeling RDR2 through Chapter 1.
At this point the game is really opened up with a nice mix of story missions, and side missions, and the ability to simply roam and explore. This afternoon after work I just went out on my new White Arabian amazing horse I found and broke (I named her Destiny - just seemed appropriate) and did some hunting. BTW - Springfield rifle with a good scope and Deadeye = perfect hides every time. After enjoying exploring the countryside, running into some stranger encounters, running into a couple of O’Driscolls and taking them out, and just enjoying the beautiful scenery, wildlife, and sounds (this game really is amazing with good headphones) I took some meat back to the camp. Shaved and upgraded Dutch’s setup (c’mon, guys, you need to contribute too, I need some upgraded saddle bags!) and then started playing poker with John, Lenny, and the butcher/provisions guy. It really felt like friends playing poker, the chat about things we’d been through, etc.
That probably sounds boring, but I chose to not pursue any “gotta do’s” or stressful missions. And still had 3 hours fly by.
And can’t wait to get back to it. Want to go find the Jack Hall gang treasure. ;)