Miyazaki’s film took the top box office spot this last weekend, which I was not expecting.
I admit that I left the theater after this having enjoyed it but also a little deflated. It is a quieter movie than most of his others (even if more grotesque as well). And, for me, less thoroughly transporting—though that’s still leaving room for a lot of incredible spectacles.
Most Miyazaki films capture you first and foremost with the portrayal of their young protagonist. Mahito is plenty interesting, but he does less to let you in (no black cat, red elk, or fire elemental to share his thoughts with) and he stews in silence.
And the logic of the world (always impressionistic in his films) is extra loose. We meet younger versions of characters alongside spirits of the dead and about-to-be-born alongside swarms of sentient animals… Weirdly the bathhouse for spirits was more coherent.
What does seem clear is that Miyazaki is thinking about the future of Ghibli and—as he said in one of the recent docs, I forget which—expecting it to not survive him. Mahito, the obvious bloodline inheritor, does not try to keep the tower standing. He goes home to be with his family, which was always his priority. And it won’t be handed off to any corporate juggernaut, either (which is what I take the ravenous parakeets and their entitled king to represent).
Robert Pattinson performance aside, I will also say that one thing I straight up didn’t care for in the film was the mystical, malevolent, mysterious heron ending up as a shoddy, incompetent, useless little imp-man. Long-time producer Toshio Suzuki has claimed that the heron represents him (and that Mahito is Miyazaki and the granduncle Isao Takahata, senior (and now deceased) founder of Ghibli. Everything in the run-up to the film and its first thirty minutes made the heron seem like a profound presence, which was then totally undercut. I trust the master has his reasons, but it was too jarring for me and didn’t seem to pay off.
Plenty to think about with this movie, though, and I am eager for a rewatch!