I just bought the new James Rollins thriller and whilst reading the description I was like “this is gonna be terrible in terms of sci-fi” and I bought it anyway b/c I kind of love the cheesiness even though I know it’s bad.
I’ve bought all of the Sigma Force books by Rollins even though many of them are not so good. From a standpoint of coherent plotline and thoughtful sci-fi thriller writing, they are… not. And yet I like them anyway.
I bet most of us have authors we read that we know are not really that good but we like them anyhow.
Harry Turtledove, David Weber, Raymond Feist, and Dewey Lambdin have been guilty pleasures over the years but the biggest one is probably George MacDonald Fraser’s Flashman series.
Ken Follett, especially his Kingsbridge novels. You can see the template and feel the gears of the exact same plot happening every time. But still, it’s so well done that I can’t help but go all in on him.
I think it was Ken at Popehat who described him as “Pulp, but sublimely executed pulp.”
Dave Sim’s Cerebus comic books and commentary, especially as the years went on. I guess I have thinner skin versus his later stuff that, at its most gussied up, is transgressive and thought-provoking, and, at its worst, is drivel dribbled from a huuuge misanthropic dick.
Yet every few years I’ll do a big Cerebus reread or Google up his latest edicts and news reports. It’s often interesting; I just feel increasingly slimy afterwards.
As a young Sharpe I greatly enjoyed the Nancy Drew and the Little House on the Prairie books. I read a lot of Nancy Drew back in the day, as in dozens of em.
Well, I have to confess I’ve read/listened to almost all of Dan Browns books (just missing the latest one). He isn’t very good, but there is a pulpy moreness to his writing, so its fun enough to get through.
Probably Jim Butcher for me - though I think he does great work, I can imagine others thinking of him as a guilty pleasure. I just finished the latest two Dresden books basically back to back and enjoyed the hell out of them. I cannot wait for the next one!
I can read all sorts of trash as long as it has a relatively competent flow of writing. Hey, at least I’m reading! I can’t handle most of the throwaway potboilers any more when they use clunky descriptions and tons of commas, but if the author has read On Writing and internalized half of it, I’ll stick around for a good action/fantasy/sci-fi romp.