Your smartphone history and reasons you replaced your old phone


Oddly enough, I found the new Samsung designs off-putting. Guess I’m a traditionalist. The wife’s getting an X, but I think I would constantly be distracted by the indent at the top of the screen.


I know it sounds like marketing spin, but your brain is really good at ignoring visual noise. I don’t even notice the notch anymore.


The notch is perfectly fine as long as you keep the phone in portrait orientation. It’s frickin’ ridiculous in landscape, but I basically never use my phone that way.


~2006: O2 XDA Exec. Windows Mobile 5.0 with touchscreen and integrated stylus. People were genuinely amazed by it when they saw me with it in the wild.

September 2010: HTC Desire

May 2012: HTC One X - returned due to manufacturing fault

September 2012: Samsung Galaxy Note 2

January 2013: LG Nexus 4 - purchased to have a smaller phone, but didn’t like it and gave it to my girlfriend

October 2013: LG Nexus 5 - battery life was so bad that I sold it after 3 days

November 2013: LG G2 - favourite phone I’ve had. Only changed because the screen smashed and it was too expensive to fix.

May 2015: Asus Zenfone 2 - buggy software, one of the worst screens i’ve ever used on a phone, and battery life was poor

May 2015: LG G4 - crap battery life, but would have kept it except it had a manufacturing defect. I dodged a bullet it seems, with the whole bootloop issue. Only phone I’ve ever had get so hot in normal use that it shut itself down.

June 2015: Samsung Galaxy S5 - cheap, boring and safe option. Was bored of trying to find a mid-range phone that wasn’t crap.

April 2017: Moto Z - so far have had to return it to the manufacturer twice for repair.

The hunt for an android phone that isn’t built like shit continues!


Wow, I’ve never had a manufacturing problem with an iPhone, ever. They work great until I replace them, every single time. That’s a dismaying list.

I did have an iPhone 5 with a bloated overheating battery, but it was 5 years old when that happened. Was using it as an ipod touch.


I’ve already decided my next phone will be an iPhone. Probably a 7 Plus. I’m not particularly wealthy, but I’m wealthy enough to pay a premium just to have guaranteed customer service and a very high likelihood of having a phone that works and will continue to work.

Last time I sent my Motorola away for repair it took 8 weeks to get it returned, and they made me feel like I was being unreasonable in chasing them up after 5 weeks had passed with no contact.


If you want to stick with Android I think you’d be fine with a Samsung flagship as well, aside from the Note 7 (obviously) they are very well made.


I don’t like aesthetic they’ve gone with for the S8, when a friend in work handed me it I thought it both looked and felt cheap. I also still really dislike touchwiz!


Alrighty. Very subjective thing.


I have been a dedicated Samsung guy but the s8 is gross.


Motorola Razr
No idea what I used in between…
Nexus G1
Nexus S
Nexus 4
Nexus 5
Nexus 5X
Nexus 6P

One or two of these I did not drop and break. I have had good practice replacing screens. I hate doing it.


Eh, you could argue that Apple should have cut the bezels on their mainstream (and still expensive!) models a bit with the 8, but for the 7 it wasn’t that weird at the time. I kinda suspect the iPhone X manufacturing process was so onerous that they didn’t have time to update anything else. I’m fairly confident the iPhone 9, all models, will have vastly reduced bezels. That’s already the rumor based on the (weirdo fancy LED) displays they’ve ordered.


The 7 was a bit long in the tooth, being the 6ss, but the 8 (6sss) is just ridiculous.


Pretty sure they wanted to, but the X took up all their efforts for that cycle. I will be deeply shocked if any 9 model has Big Bezel when October 2018 rolls around.

I don’t think many people consider bezels a true deal breaker at this point. It is slightly behind the times, yes, but not a deal breaker. And there’s always the premium X if you Just Gotta Have It.