I would have voted in GOTY if I had never went to Arx.
Interestingly, I noticed how so many of the “reviews” on Steam have < 60 hrs played. No way you can finish that game in under 60 hours. Looking at the achievements, only 6% have completed in Classic mode.
I know I’ve been guilty (heck I never completed DOS1, and I kickstarted DOS2!), so can’t blame other’s exhuberence when it’s such a long game, but I think we should have two types of reviews: 1 for those who have completed the game & 1 where you haven’t. It would be an interesting way to look at it.